| Date | Opponent | Status | Result | Links | |
| Sep. 1 | at Messiah | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 4 | at Elizabethtown @ Westminster, Md. | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| at McDaniel | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | ||
| Sep. 7 | at Gettysburg | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 10 | Elizabethtown @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | W, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| Dickinson College Invitational | |||||
| Lebanon Valley @ Dickinson | Final | W, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | ||
| Dickinson College Invitational | |||||
| Sep. 11 | at Dickinson | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| Dickinson College Invitational | |||||
| at Bridgewater (Va.) @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | ||
| Dickinson College Invitational | |||||
| Sep. 15 | at Hood * | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 17 | at Wesley @ Aston, Pa. | Final | W, 3-0 | Preview Box Score Recap | |
| Neumann Knights' Invitational | |||||
| at Marywood @ Aston, Pa. | Final | W, 3-0 | Preview Box Score Recap | ||
| Neumann Knights' Invitational | |||||
| Sep. 18 | at Neumann | Final | W, 3-1 | Preview Box Score Recap | |
| Neumann Knights' Invitational | |||||
| at Widener @ Aston, Pa. | Final | W, 3-1 | Preview Box Score | ||
| Neumann Knights' Invitational | |||||
| Sep. 24 | Johns Hopkins | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | |||||
| Carnegie Mellon | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Recap | ||
| York College Spartan Invitational | |||||
| Sep. 25 | Rutgers-Camden | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | |||||
| Va. Wesleyan | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | ||
| York College Spartan Invitational | |||||
| Oct. 2 | Mary Washington * | Final | W, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 5 | Stevenson * | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 8 | Wash. & Jeff. @ Selinsgrove, Pa. | Final | W, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| Fifth Annual Hampton Inn Crusader Classic | |||||
| Rowan @ Susquehanna | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | ||
| Fifth Annual Hampton Inn Crusader Classic | |||||
| Oct. 9 | at Susquehanna | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Fifth Annual Hampton Inn Crusader Classic | |||||
| Albright @ Selinsgrove, Pa. | Final | W, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | ||
| Fifth Annual Hampton Inn Crusader Classic | |||||
| Oct. 12 | at St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 13 | at Catholic | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 16 | at Frostburg St. * | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| at Penn St.-Altoona @ Frostburg, Md. | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | ||
| Oct. 19 | Wesley * | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 21 | Marymount (Va.) * | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 27 | at Salisbury * | Final | L, 3-2 | Preview Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 29 | at Goucher | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Nov. 2 | at St. Mary's (Md.) | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| CAC First Round | |||||
| Nov. 4 | at Frostburg St. | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Semifinals | |||||
| Sep. 1 | at Messiah | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 3 | Elizabethtown | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Westminster (Pa.) | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| Sep. 6 | Salisbury * | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 9 | at Lycoming @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Dickinson College Red Devil Invitational | |||||
| at Mich.-Dearborn @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| Dickinson College Red Devil Invitational | |||||
| Sep. 10 | at Lebanon Valley @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Dickinson College Red Devil Invitational | |||||
| at Dickinson | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| Dickinson College Red Devil Invitational | |||||
| Sep. 14 | Hood * | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap Photos | |
| Sep. 16 | Gettysburg | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap Photos | |
| Sep. 17 | at Swarthmore @ Salisbury, Md. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Haverford @ Salisbury University (Salisbury, Md.) | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| Sep. 20 | at Marymount (Va.) * | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 23 | SUNYIT | Final | W, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap Photos | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | |||||
| Swarthmore | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap Photos | ||
| York College Spartan Invitational | |||||
| Sep. 24 | Centenary (N.J.) | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | |||||
| Salisbury | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| York (Pa.) College Tournament | |||||
| Sep. 29 | St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 5 | at Mary Washington * | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 12 | at Stevenson * | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 14 | at UC Santa Cruz @ Colorado Springs, Col. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| 2011 Molten Spike It Up Classic | |||||
| at Colorado Col. | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| 2011 Molten Spike It Up Classic | |||||
| Oct. 15 | Chapman @ Colorado Springs, Col. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| 2011 Molten Spike It Up Classic | |||||
| Webster @ Colorado Springs, Col. | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| 2011 Molten Spike It Up Classic | |||||
| Oct. 19 | Frostburg St. * | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 21 | at Wesley * | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 22 | at Randolph-Macon @ Eastern | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Eastern | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| Oct. 26 | at Susquehanna | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 29 | Goucher | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Penn St.-Berks | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | ||
| Nov. 1 | at Frostburg St. | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Tournament - First Round | |||||
| Nov. 3 | at Stevenson | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Semifinals | |||||
| Aug. 31 | at Fredonia St. @ Cortland, NY | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Cortland Tournament | |||||
| at Richard Stockton @ Cortland, NY | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| Cortland Tournament | |||||
| Sep. 1 | at Lebanon Valley @ Cortland, NY | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| Cortland Tournament | |||||
| at Pitt.-Bradford @ Cortland, NY | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| Cortland Tournament | |||||
| Sep. 5 | Frank. & Marsh. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 7 | at Lycoming @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Dickinson College Tournament | |||||
| at Mich.-Dearborn @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Recap | ||
| Dickinson College Tournament | |||||
| Sep. 8 | Lebanon Valley @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Dickinson College Tournament | |||||
| at Dickinson | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap Recap | ||
| Sep. 12 | at Salisbury * | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 14 | at Swarthmore @ Hoboken, N.J. | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Stevens Ducks Classic | |||||
| at Stevens | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | ||
| Stevens Ducks Classic | |||||
| Sep. 15 | at Buffalo St. @ Hoboken, N.J. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| Stevens Ducks Classic | |||||
| Kean @ Hoboken, N.J. | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| Stevens Ducks Classic | |||||
| Sep. 18 | Wesley * | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 21 | at Elizabethtown | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Blue Jay Classic | |||||
| Rochester (N.Y.) @ Elizabethtown, Pa. | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Recap | ||
| Blue Jay Classic | |||||
| Sep. 22 | Hamilton @ Elizabethtown | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Blue Jay Classic | |||||
| Ramapo @ Elizabethtown, Pa. | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| Blue Jay Classic | |||||
| Sep. 25 | at Frostburg St. * | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap Recap | |
| Sep. 28 | Centenary (N.J.) | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | |||||
| Eastern | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | ||
| York College Spartan Invitational | |||||
| Sep. 29 | Rowan | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Box Score Box Score Recap Recap Video Video | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | |||||
| Cortland St. | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | ||
| York College Spartan Invitational | |||||
| Oct. 3 | Marymount (Va.) * | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 9 | at Goucher | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 13 | at Johns Hopkins @ Haverford, Pa. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| at Haverford | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| Oct. 18 | at St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 20 | at Gettysburg @ Allentown, Pa. | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Muhlenberg | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | ||
| Oct. 23 | Mary Washington * | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 27 | at Pitt.-Bradford @ Altoona, Pa. | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Penn St.-Altoona | Final | W, 3-1 | Box Score Recap | ||
| Nov. 1 | at St. Mary's (Md.) | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap Live stats | |
| CAC Tournament - First Round | |||||
| Home games in bold. * = Conference games. | |||||