| Date | Opponent | Time | Score | |
| 11/7/09 | vs. Monarch Invitational @ Wilkes Barre, PA | Final | Results Recap | |
| Sixth of 10 Teams, 70.5 points | ||||
| 11/7/09 | vs. Drexel @ University of Maryland | Final | L, 37-9 | Box Score Recap |
| 11/7/09 | at #10 Maryland | Final | L, 57-0 | Box Score Recap |
| 11/11/09 | McDaniel | Final | L, 22-19 | Box Score Recap Video |
| 11/14/09 | vs. Mount St. Joesph @ Wilkes-Barre, Pa. | Final | W, 26-15 | Box Score Recap |
| John Reese Duals @ Wilkes University | ||||
| 11/14/09 | vs. Scranton @ Wilkes-Barre, Pa. | Final | W, 44-3 | Box Score Recap |
| John Reese Duals @ Wilkes University | ||||
| 11/14/09 | vs. New York @ Wilkes-Barre, Pa. | Final | L, 30-8 | Box Score Recap |
| John Reese Duals @ Wilkes University | ||||
| 11/14/09 | vs. Ithaca @ Wilkes-Barre, Pa. | Final | L, 22-13 | Box Score Recap |
| John Reese Duals @ Wilkes University | ||||
| 11/21/09 | vs. Baldwin-Wallace @ Waynesburg, Pa. | Final | L, 26-8 | Box Score Recap |
| 11/21/09 | vs. Messiah @ Waynesburg, Pa. | Final | L, 23-18 | Box Score Recap |
| 11/21/09 | at Waynesburg | Final | W, 27-13 | Box Score Recap |
| 12/5/09 | New Standard Corporation Spartan Invitational | Final | Results Recap Video | |
| 7th of 10 Teams, 56.5 points | ||||
| 12/12/09 | Penn State DuBois | Final | W, 33-16 | Box Score Recap Video |
| York College Quad Meet | ||||
| 12/12/09 | Muhlenberg | Final | W, 42-4 | Box Score Recap Video |
| York College Quad Meet | ||||
| 12/12/09 | Wilkes | Final | L, 34-6 | Box Score Recap Video |
| York College Quad Meet | ||||
| 1/9/10 | vs. Johns Hopkins @ Collegeville, Pa. | Final | W, 24-11 | Box Score Recap |
| North/South Duals | ||||
| 1/9/10 | vs. Wesleyan @ Collegeville, Pa. | Final | L, 34-6 | Box Score Recap |
| North/South Duals | ||||
| 1/9/10 | vs. Ursinus @ Collegeville, Pa. | Final | L, 24-16 | Box Score Recap |
| North/South Duals | ||||
| 1/9/10 | vs. Cortland @ Collegeville, Pa. | Final | L, 37-6 | Box Score Recap |
| North/South Duals | ||||
| 1/12/10 | at New Jersey | Final | L, 38-0 | Box Score Recap |
| TCNJ Tri-Match | ||||
| 1/12/10 | vs. Centenary @ Ewing, N.J. | Final | L, 24-10 | Box Score Recap |
| TCNJ Tri-Match | ||||
| 1/15/10 | vs. Ithaca @ Williamsport, Pa. | Final | L, 36-12 | Box Score Recap |
| Budd Whitehill Duals | ||||
| 1/15/10 | vs. Ohio Northern @ Williamsport, Pa. | Final | L, 29-14 | Box Score Recap |
| Budd Whitehill Duals | ||||
| 1/16/10 | vs. Olivet @ Williamsport, Pa. | Final | W, 22-21 | Box Score Recap |
| Budd Whitehill Duals | ||||
| 1/16/10 | vs. Thiel @ Williamsport, Pa. | Final | W, 26-10 | Box Score Recap |
| Budd Whitehill Duals | ||||
| 1/23/10 | Kings | Final | L, 20-12 | Box Score Recap |
| 1/28/10 | at Shippensburg | Final | L, 39-7 | Box Score Recap |
| 2/21/10 | vs. Metropolitan Conference Championships @ Trenton, N.J. | Final | Preview Results Recap | |
| 7th of 9 Teams (35.5 Points) | ||||
| Home games in bold. * = Conference games. | ||||