| Date | Opponent | Status | Result | Links |
| Aug. 31 | at Fredonia St. @ Cortland, NY | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Box Score Box Score Recap Recap |
| Cortland Tournament | ||||
| Alvernia | Final | L, 4-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| York College Tournament Kean vs. Randolph-Macon - 3:00 pm | ||||
| at Va. Wesleyan @ Newport News, Va. | Final | W, 5-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Ursinus @ Reading, Pa. | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Alvernia University Tournament | ||||
| at Richard Stockton @ Cortland, NY | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Cortland Tournament | ||||
| Sep. 1 | at Galen Piper Cross Country Challenge | Final | Results Recap | |
| @ Shippensburg University - Shippensburg, Pa. | ||||
| at Lebanon Valley @ Cortland, NY | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Cortland Tournament | ||||
| Randolph-Macon | Final | W, 6-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| York College Classic Consolation Game | ||||
| at Pitt.-Bradford @ Cortland, NY | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Cortland Tournament | ||||
| at Alvernia | Final - 2OT | T, 0-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Alvernia University Tournament Championship Game | ||||
| Sep. 2 | at Chris. Newport | Final | W, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Christopher Newport Tournament | ||||
| Sep. 5 | Gettysburg | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Frank. & Marsh. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Box Score Box Score Recap Recap | |
| at Elizabethtown | Final - 2OT | T, 0-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 7 | at Lycoming @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Dickinson College Tournament | ||||
| at Mich.-Dearborn @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Dickinson College Tournament | ||||
| Sep. 8 | McDaniel | Final | W, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Holiday Inn Conference Center Soccer Classic - York, Pa. William Paterson vs. Susquehanna - 3:00 pm | ||||
| Lebanon Valley @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Dickinson College Tournament | ||||
| at Washington and Lee | Final | W, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Dickinson | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Box Score Box Score Recap Recap | |
| Sep. 9 | Maritime (N.Y.) | Final | W, 10-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Susquehanna | Final | L, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Holiday Inn Conference Center Soccer Classic Championship Game | ||||
| Sep. 11 | at Messiah College Fall Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| (15-1) | ||||
| Sep. 12 | Alvernia | Final - 2OT | T, 0-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Dickinson | Final | L, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Salisbury * | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 13 | at East. Mennonite | Final | W, 4-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Sep. 14 | at Swarthmore @ Hoboken, N.J. | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Stevens Ducks Classic | ||||
| at Stevens | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Stevens Ducks Classic | ||||
| Sep. 15 | Rich Achtzehn Classic | Final | Preview Results Recap | |
| @ John Rudy County Park - York, Pa. | ||||
| at Buffalo St. @ Hoboken, N.J. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Box Score Box Score Recap Recap | |
| Stevens Ducks Classic | ||||
| Catholic | Final | L, 9-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Catholic | Final | W, 5-4 | Box Score Recap | |
| Kean @ Hoboken, N.J. | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Stevens Ducks Classic | ||||
| at St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final - 2OT | T, 0-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Wesley * | Final | W, 4-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 17 | at Bent Creek Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| (25-6) | ||||
| at Lycoming | Final | W, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 18 | Penn St.-Harrisburg | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Wesley * | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Shenandoah | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap Video | |
| Sep. 19 | Johns Hopkins | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Sep. 21 | at PSU Harrisburg Invitational | Final | ||
| at Messiah | Final | L, 7-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| at Messiah | Final | W, 6-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| at Elizabethtown | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Box Score Box Score Recap Recap | |
| Blue Jay Classic | ||||
| Rochester (N.Y.) @ Elizabethtown, Pa. | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Blue Jay Classic | ||||
| Sep. 22 | at PSU Harrisburg Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| (30-15) | ||||
| at Frostburg St. Invitational | Final | Results Recap | ||
| Maplehurst Country Club - Frostburg, Md. | ||||
| Hamilton @ Elizabethtown | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Blue Jay Classic | ||||
| at Mary Washington * | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Neumann | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Marymount (Va.) * | Final | W, 2-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Ramapo @ Elizabethtown, Pa. | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Box Score Box Score Recap Recap | |
| Blue Jay Classic | ||||
| Sep. 23 | at Stevenson | Final | W, 9-0 | Box Score Recap |
| at Stevenson | Final | W, 9-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Sep. 24 | McDaniel | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Sep. 25 | at Elizabethtown | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Frostburg St. * | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Box Score Box Score Recap Recap | |
| Sep. 26 | at Messiah | Final - 2OT | L, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Sep. 28 | at Grove City @ York | Final | L, 3-0 | |
| at Cortland St. @ York (Pa.) | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Video | |
| Centenary (N.J.) | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | ||||
| at Eastern @ York | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score | |
| at Stevenson @ York (Pa.) | Final | L, 3-0 | Video | |
| at Grove City @ York | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | ||||
| Eastern | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | ||||
| at Rowan @ York | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score | |
| Sep. 29 | at Dickinson College Long/Short Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| @ Big Spring High School - Carlisle, Pa. | ||||
| at Fall ITA Regionals @ Fredericksburg, Va. | TBA | Recap | ||
| @ UMW | ||||
| at Grove City @ York (Pa.) | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score | |
| at Cortland St. @ York, Pa. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | ||||
| Rowan | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Box Score Box Score Recap Recap Video Video | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | ||||
| at Eastern @ York | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score | |
| Salisbury * | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Cortland St. | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Box Score Box Score Recap Recap | |
| York College Spartan Invitational | ||||
| at Centenary (N.J.) @ York, PA | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score | |
| Salisbury * | Final - 2OT | W, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| York later vacated the contest by NCAA ruling | ||||
| at Eastern @ York (Pa.) | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score | |
| at Rowan @ York, Pa. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score | |
| Oct. 2 | Goucher | Final - 2OT | T, 0-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Oct. 3 | at Penn St.-Harrisburg | Final | W, 6-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| York later vacated the contest by NCAA ruling | ||||
| Marymount (Va.) * | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 4 | at Elizabethtown Fall Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| (41-19) | ||||
| Stevenson | Final | W, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 5 | at Penn St.-Harrisburg | Final | W, 8-1 | Box Score Recap |
| at Penn St.-Harrisburg | Final | W, 8-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 6 | at Goucher College Classic | Final | Results Recap | |
| @ Goucher College - Towson, Md. | ||||
| Ursinus | Final | L, 7-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| Mary Washington * | Final - 2OT | T, 0-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Lynchburg | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Goucher | Final | L, 6-3 | Box Score Recap | |
| at Goucher | Final | W, 6-3 | Box Score Recap | |
| Marymount (Va.) * | Final | W, 8-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| York later vacated the contest by NCAA ruling | ||||
| Oct. 8 | at Lebanon Valley Fall Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| (49-24) | ||||
| Oct. 9 | at DeSales | Final | W, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Goucher | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 10 | Gettysburg | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Gettysburg | Final - 2OT | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 12 | at Wesley * | Final - OT | L, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Oct. 13 | at Christopher Newport Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| @ Christopher Newport - Newport News, Va. | ||||
| Salisbury * | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Johns Hopkins @ Haverford, Pa. | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Box Score Box Score Recap Recap | |
| at St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | W, 4-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Haverford | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 16 | Rhodes | Final | L, 5-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Oct. 17 | Frostburg St. * | Final | T, 1-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Frostburg St. * | Final | L, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 18 | Frostburg St. * | Final | W, 5-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap Video |
| at St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 20 | at St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Gettysburg @ Allentown, Pa. | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Mary Washington * | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Muhlenberg | Final | L, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Wesley * | Final | W, 2-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 23 | at Catholic | Final - 2OT | T, 0-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Mary Washington * | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 24 | Susquehanna | Final | W, 7-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Manhattanville | Final | W, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Oct. 27 | at Capital Athletic Conference Championships | Final | Results Recap | |
| @ Frostburg University - Frostburg, Md. | ||||
| Wesley | Final - PK Home | T, 0-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Tournament - First Round | ||||
| St. Mary's (Md.) | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Tournament - First Round | ||||
| at Pitt.-Bradford @ Altoona, Pa. | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| St. Mary's (Md.) | Final | L, 2-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Tournament - First Round | ||||
| at Penn St.-Altoona | Final | W, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Nov. 1 | at Frostburg St. | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| CAC Tournament - Semifinals | ||||
| at Frostburg St. | Final - 2OT | W, 4-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Tournament - Semifinals | ||||
| at St. Mary's (Md.) | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap Live stats | |
| CAC Tournament - First Round | ||||
| Nov. 2 | at Mary Washington * | 6:00 pm | L, 210-52 | Results Recap |
| at Mary Washington * | Final | L, 201-61 | Results Recap | |
| Nov. 3 | Marymount (Va.) * | 2:00 pm | L, 107-98 | Results Recap |
| Marymount (Va.) * | 2:00 pm | W, 104-93 | Results Recap | |
| at Kings College Monarch Classic | Final | Results Recap | ||
| @ Kings College - Wilkes-Barre, Pa. | ||||
| Mary Washington | Final | W, 5-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Tournament - Championship Game | ||||
| Nov. 10 | St. Mary's * | Final | L, 159-44 | Results Recap |
| Dickinson | Final | L, 143-60 | Results Recap | |
| Susquehanna | Final | L, 146.5-56.5 | Results Recap | |
| St. Mary's * | Final | T, 102-102 | Results Recap | |
| Dickinson | Final | L, 128-76 | Results Recap | |
| Susquehanna | Final | L, 110-94 | Results Recap | |
| at King's @ Wilkes-Barre, Pa. | Final | W, 34-7 | Box Score Recap | |
| John Reese Duals @ Wilkes University | ||||
| at Centenary @ Wilkes-Barre, Pa. | Final | L, 23-12 | Box Score Recap | |
| John Reese Duals @ Wilkes University | ||||
| at NYU @ Wilkes-Barre, Pa. | Final | W, 37-3 | Box Score Recap | |
| John Reese Duals @ Wilkes University | ||||
| at Oneonta @ Wilkes-Barre, Pa. | Final | W, 33-9 | Box Score Recap | |
| John Reese Duals @ Wilkes University | ||||
| at NCAA Mideast Regional Championships | Final | Results Recap | ||
| @ Big Spring High School - Carlisle, Pa. | ||||
| St. Joseph's (L.I.) | Final | W, 1-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| NCAA Tournament - First Round | ||||
| Nov. 11 | Rutgers-Camden | Final - PK Home | T, 0-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| NCAA Tournament - Second Round | ||||
| Nov. 15 | Lycoming | Final | W, 35-9 | Results Recap |
| Johns Hopkins | Final | W, 55-44 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Nov. 16 | Baruch @ Scranton, Pa. | Final | L, 72-55 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Radisson Invitational | ||||
| Nov. 17 | Washington & Jefferson | Final | L, 156-98 | Results Recap |
| Washington & Jefferson | Final | L, 158-102 | Results Recap | |
| Wayesburg @ Painesville, Ohio | Final | W, 22-15 | Box Score Recap | |
| Lake Erie Quad Meet | ||||
| Tiffin @ Painesville, Ohio | Final | L, 31-13 | Box Score Recap | |
| Lake Erie Quad Meet | ||||
| at Lake Erie | Final | L, 19-18 | Box Score Recap | |
| Lake Erie Quad Meet - Painesville, Ohio | ||||
| at NCAA National Championship Meet | 12:00 pm | |||
| @ Terre Haute, Indiana | ||||
| at Messiah @ York College, York, PA | Final - PK Home | T, 2-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| NCAA Tournament - Third Round | ||||
| at Oneonta St. @ Long Center, Scranton, Pa. | Final | L, 92-77 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Radisson Invitational Consolation Game | ||||
| at Roanoke @ Guilford, N.C. | Final | W, 57-34 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Daly Seven Hotels Classic | ||||
| Nov. 18 | at Guilford | Final | W, 55-51 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Daly Seven Hotels Classic | ||||
| Nov. 20 | Messiah | Final | L, 75-62 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Nov. 25 | at Gettysburg | Final | W, 63-58 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Gettysburg | Final | W, 55-44 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Nov. 27 | at Goucher | Final | W, 74-45 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Nov. 30 | Salisbury * | Final | W, 106-98 | Results Recap |
| Goucher | Final | W, 127-75 | Results Recap | |
| Salisbury * | Final | W, 112-92 | Results Recap | |
| Goucher | Final | L, 129-73 | Results Recap | |
| Dec. 1 | at DuCharme Indoor @ Carlisle, Pa. | Final | Results Recap | |
| Dickinson College | ||||
| New Standard Corporation Invitational | Final | Results Recap | ||
| 3rd of 13 Teams, 66.5 points | ||||
| at St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | W, 62-48 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | L, 58-50 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Dec. 4 | Frank. & Marsh. | Final | W, 67-41 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Dec. 5 | at Gettysburg | Final | W, 25-14 | Box Score Recap |
| at Penn St.-Abington | Final | L, 90-79 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Dec. 7 | Gallaudet | Final | W, 63-31 | Results Recap |
| PSU-Altoona | Final | W, 65-28 | Results Recap | |
| Gallaudet | Final | W, 86-9 | Results Recap | |
| PSU-Altoona | Final | W, 64-31 | Results Recap | |
| Messiah | Final | W, 22-19 | Results Recap | |
| Dec. 8 | at Elizabethtown | Final | W, 107-97 | Box Score Recap |
| at Elizabethtown | Final | W, 105-89 | Box Score Recap | |
| at Wesley * | Final | W, 67-35 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Wesley * | Final | W, 77-69 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Dec. 11 | at Penn St.-Harrisburg | Final | W, 90-71 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Dec. 21 | Kalamazoo @ Memphis, Tenn. | Final | L, 72-64 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Rhodes College Christmas Invitational | ||||
| Dec. 22 | at Knox @ Memphis, Tenn. | Final | W, 93-52 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Rhodes College Christmas Invitational Consolation Game | ||||
| Dec. 28 | Grove City | Final | L, 65-60 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Coaches vs. Cancer Classic - York, Pa. | ||||
| Dec. 29 | Farmingdale State | Final | L, 70-61 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Coaches vs. Cancer Classic - York, Pa. Consolation Game | ||||
| Wheaton (Mass.) | Final | W, 55-54 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Coaches vs. Cancer Classic - York, Pa. | ||||
| Dec. 30 | TCNJ | Final | W, 56-48 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Coaches vs. Cancer Classic - York, Pa. Championship Game | ||||
| Jan. 3 | Elizabethtown | Final | W, 66-55 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Jan. 5 | at TCNJ @ Collegeville, Pa. | Final | W, 21-20 | Results Recap |
| North/South Duals | ||||
| at Rhode Island @ Collegeville, Pa. | Final | W, 26-15 | Results Recap | |
| North/South Duals | ||||
| at Wilkes @ Collegeville, Pa. | Final | L, 31-3 | Results Recap | |
| North/South Duals | ||||
| at McDaniel @ Collegeville, Pa. | Final | W, 20-18 | Results Recap | |
| North/South Duals | ||||
| Richard Stockton | Final | L, 61-51 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Misericordia | Final | W, 73-55 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Jan. 7 | Catholic | Final | L, 60-52 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Jan. 9 | Salisbury * | Final | L, 66-53 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Salisbury * | Final | L, 61-58 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Jan. 11 | at Thiel @ Williamsport, Pa. | Final | W, 25-15 | Preview Results Recap |
| Budd Whitehill Duals | ||||
| at Case Western Reserve @ Williamsport, Pa. | Final | W, 49-0 | Preview Results Recap | |
| Budd Whitehill Duals | ||||
| at TCNJ @ Williamsport, Pa. | Final | W, 17-16 | Results Recap | |
| Budd Whitehill Duals | ||||
| Jan. 12 | Ursinus | Final | L, 146-103 | Results Recap |
| Ursinus | Final | L, 153-102 | Results Recap | |
| at Wisconsin-Stevens Point @ Williamsport, Pa. | Final | L, 25-11 | Preview Results Recap | |
| Lycoming College | ||||
| at Wabash @ Williamsport, Pa. | Final | W, 24-13 | Results Recap | |
| Budd Whitehill Duals | ||||
| Marymount (Va.) * | Final | W, 57-44 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Marymount (Va.) * | Final | W, 78-62 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Jan. 14 | at Rowan | Final | L, 149-106 | Results Recap |
| at Rowan | Final | L, 166-82 | Results Recap | |
| Jan. 16 | at Frostburg St. * | Final | W, 56-40 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Frostburg St. * | Final | L, 70-47 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Jan. 19 | at Maryland Terrapin Invitational @ College Park, Md. | Final | Results Recap | |
| at Maryland Terrapin Invitational @ College Park, Md. | Final | Results Recap | ||
| at Frostburg St. * | Final | W, 110-78 | Results Recap | |
| at Frostburg St. * | Final | W, 120-59 | Results Recap | |
| at Millersville @ Millersville, Pa. | Final | W, 27-15 | Results Recap | |
| Mid-Penn Duals - Semifinals | ||||
| at Franklin & Marshall @ Millersville, Pa. | Final | W, 22-16 | Results Recap | |
| Mid-Penn Duals Championship Match | ||||
| Mary Washington * | Final | L, 50-47 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mary Washington * | Final | L, 64-47 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Jan. 21 | at McDaniel | Final | W, 63-45 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Elizabethtown | Final | W, 61-59 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Jan. 24 | Washington and Lee | Final | W, 61-48 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Jan. 26 | at George Mason Patriot Games @ Fairfax, Va. | Final | Results Recap | |
| at George Mason Patriot Games @ Fairfax, Va. | Final | Results Recap | ||
| St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | W, 77-54 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | L, 84-51 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Jan. 30 | at Marymount (Va.) * | Final | L, 53-44 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Marymount (Va.) * | Final | L, 67-44 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Feb. 1 | at Susquehanna Crusader Classic @ Selinsgrove, Pa. | Final | Results Recap | |
| Feb. 2 | PSU-Mont Alto | Final | W, 58-0 | Results Recap |
| Cortland St. | Final | L, 31-6 | Results Recap | |
| Thaddeus Stevens | Final | W, 58-0 | Results Recap | |
| at Salisbury * | Final | W, 72-50 | Box Score Box Score Recap Video | |
| at Salisbury * | Final | L, 63-60 | Box Score Box Score Recap Video | |
| Feb. 4 | at Alvernia | Final | L, 66-55 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Feb. 9 | at Susquehanna University Invitational @ Selinsgrove, Pa. | 9:30 am | Results Recap | |
| Wesley * | Final | W, 69-39 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Wesley * | Final | L, 69-61 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Feb. 13 | at Mary Washington * | Final | L, 76-67 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Mary Washington * | Final | L, 58-44 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Feb. 15 | at CAC Championships | Final | Results Recap | |
| 4th of 6 Teams, 115 Pts. | ||||
| at CAC Championships | Final | Results Recap | ||
| 4th of 6 Teams, 100 Pts. | ||||
| at Elizabethtown | Final | L, 25-19 | Results Recap | |
| Feb. 16 | at CAC Championships | Final | Results Recap | |
| 4th of 6 teams with 276 Pts. | ||||
| at CAC Championships | Final | Results Recap | ||
| 3rd of 6 teams with 274 Pts. | ||||
| Frostburg St. * | Final | W, 83-44 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Ferrum @ Atlanta, Ga. | Final | L, 9-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Emory Invitational | ||||
| Frostburg St. * | Final | L, 64-60 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Emory | Final - 5 innings | L, 9-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap Video | |
| Emory Invitational | ||||
| Feb. 17 | at Capital Athletic Conference Indoor Championships @ Fairfax, Va. * | Final | Results Recap | |
| @ George Mason University | ||||
| at CAC Championships | Final | Results Recap | ||
| 4th of 6 Teams, 401 Pts. | ||||
| at CAC Championships | Final | Results Recap | ||
| 3rd of 6 Teams, 407 Pts. | ||||
| Ferrum @ Atlanta, Ga. | Final | L, 6-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Emory Invitational | ||||
| at Emory | Final - 5 innings | L, 9-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Emory Invitational | ||||
| Feb. 19 | Frostburg St. | Final | W, 74-38 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| CAC Tournament - First Round | ||||
| at Salisbury | Final | L, 80-60 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC First Round | ||||
| Feb. 21 | at Mary Washington | Final | L, 55-49 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| CAC Tournament Semifinal | ||||
| Feb. 23 | at Goucher | Final | W, 18-10 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Muhlenberg | Final | W, 15-10 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Feb. 24 | at George Mason Last Chance Meet @ Fairfax, Va. | Final | Recap | |
| at Lynchburg | Final | W, 7-4 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Lynchburg | Final | L, 3-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Feb. 26 | at Frank. & Marsh. | Final | L, 13-6 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Feb. 27 | Scranton | Final | W, 17-4 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Mar. 1 | at Richard Stockton | Final - 8 innings | W, 5-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Mar. 2 | at Virginia Tech Last Chance Meet @ Blacksburg, Va. | Final | Recap Live stats | |
| at Virginia Tech Last Chance Meet @ Blacksburg, Va. | Final | Live stats | ||
| at NCAA Regional Qualifier @ Ohio Northern University - Ada, Ohio | Final | Recap | ||
| 8th of 16 Teams, 60 Points | ||||
| at McDaniel | Final | W, 9-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 3 | Grand Rapids @ Hilton Head Resort | Final | L, 6-3 | Box Score Recap |
| Mar. 4 | Lebanon Valley @ Hilton Head Middle School | Final | L, 9-0 | Box Score Recap |
| at Ursinus @ Myrtle Beach, S.C. | Final | W, 6-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Snowbird Softball | ||||
| Randolph @ Myrtle Beach, S.C. | Final | L, 4-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| 2013 Spring Trip | ||||
| Mar. 5 | at Eastern Nazarene @ at Hilton Head Island, S.C. | Final | L, 6-3 | Box Score Recap |
| at Eastern @ Myrtle Beach, SC | Final | L, 5-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| 2013 Spring Trip | ||||
| at King's (Pa.) @ Myrtle Beach, SC | Final | L, 4-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| 2013 Spring Trip | ||||
| Catholic @ Myrtle Beach, S.C. | Final | L, 12-4 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Griffith Field | ||||
| Alvernia @ Orlando, Fla. | Final | W, 16-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 6 | at Malone @ Hilton Head, SC | Final | W, 5-4 | Box Score Recap |
| at N.C. Wesleyan @ Myrtle Beach, S.C. | Final | W, 12-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Ursinus @ Myrtle Beach, S.C. | Final - 5 innings | L, 15-6 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Snowbird Softball | ||||
| Penn St.-Hazleton @ Myrtle Beach, S.C. | Final | W, 6-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| 2013 Spring Trip | ||||
| Mt. Aloysius @ Myrtle Beach, S.C. | Final | W, 10-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Polo Grounds | ||||
| Mar. 7 | St. Louis Pharmacy @ Hilton Head Resort | Final | L, 5-4 | Box Score Recap |
| St. Louis Pharmacy @ Hilton Head Resort | Final | W, 8-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| at Eastern @ Myrtle Beach, S.C. | Final | L, 8-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Ebbets Field | ||||
| Penn St.-Hazleton @ Myrtle Beach, SC | Final - 5 innings | W, 9-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| 2013 Spring Trip | ||||
| Ursinus @ Clearwater, Fla. | Final | W, 12-4 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Penn St.-Harrisburg @ Myrtle Beach, SC | Final | W, 4-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Alvernia @ Hilton Head, S.C. | Final | L, 6-3 | Box Score Recap | |
| Alvernia @ Hilton Head, S.C. | Final | W, 7-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| at Haverford | Final | L, 14-8 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 9 | Scranton | Final | L, 11-8 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Randolph-Macon | Final | W, 15-13 | Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 11 | Shenandoah | Final | L, 6-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Shenandoah | Final - 8 innings | L, 5-3 | Box Score Recap Live stats | |
| Mar. 13 | at Salisbury * | Final | L, 8-1 | Box Score Recap |
| at Salisbury * | Final | L, 8-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| Elizabethtown | Final | W, 9-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Catholic | Final | W, 13-8 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Salisbury * | Final | L, 9-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 15 | at NCAA Division III National Championships @ Cedar Rapids, Iowa | Final | Recap | |
| Pisani advances to 149 Semis | ||||
| Mary Washington * | Final | L, 6-3 | Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 16 | Green-White Inter-Squad Alumni Challenge @ York, Pa. | 10:00 am | ||
| at NCAA Division III National Championships @ Cedar Rapids, Iowa | Final | Recap | ||
| Pisani Finishes 4th at 149 | ||||
| at Salisbury * | Final | L, 6-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Stevens | Final | W, 11-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Salisbury * | Final | L, 6-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Frank. & Marsh. | Final | W, 9-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 17 | at Salisbury * | Final | L, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Mar. 20 | at Messiah | Final | W, 8-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Marywood | Final | W, 15-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 21 | Susquehanna | Final - 8 innings | L, 2-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Dickinson | Final | W, 9-4 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Susquehanna | Final | L, 13-6 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 23 | at West Chester Golden Ram Invitational @ West Chester, Pa. | Final | Results Recap | |
| at Gettysburg Invitational | Final | Box Score Recap | ||
| The Bridges Golf Club | ||||
| Southern Va. | Final | W, 7-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| Southern Va. | Final | W, 9-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Wesley * | Final | L, 2-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | W, 14-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Wesley * | Final | W, 8-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Wesley * | Final | W, 17-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 24 | Wesley * | Final | L, 5-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Mar. 26 | at Messiah | Final | L, 17-15 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Misericordia | Final | W, 18-6 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 27 | at Elizabethtown Capital Area Classic @ Elizabethtown, Pa. | Final | Recap | |
| at Wesley * | Final | W, 9-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| at Wesley * | Final | W, 9-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 28 | East. Mennonite | Final | L, 8-6 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| East. Mennonite | Final | L, 5-4 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Randolph-Macon | Final | L, 9-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 29 | Marymount (Va.) * | Final | W, 22-4 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | L, 4-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mar. 30 | at Best Western North Florida Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| Randolph-Macon | Final | L, 5-4 | Box Score Recap | |
| St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | W, 6-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Salisbury * | Final - 5 innings | L, 17-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Chris. Newport | Final | W, 17-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Salisbury * | Final - 5 innings | L, 11-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 1 | at Lebanon Valley Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| Lebanon Country Club | ||||
| Messiah | Final | L, 7-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Shenandoah | Final | L, 8-4 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Messiah | Final | L, 5-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 3 | at DeSales | Final | Results Recap | |
| Brookside Country Club | ||||
| Messiah | Final | W, 6-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Ursinus | Final | L, 10-9 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 4 | at Elizabethtown Spring Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| Hershey Links Golf Club | ||||
| at Frank. & Marsh. | Final | L, 9-8 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Susquehanna | Final | W, 10-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Frank. & Marsh. | Final - 6 innings | L, 11-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 5 | at Gettysburg | Final | L, 9-0 | Box Score Recap |
| at Gettysburg | Final | L, 5-4 | Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 6 | Green and White Invitational @ York, Pa. | Final | Results Recap | |
| Mary Washington * | Final | W, 5-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Marymount (Va.) * | Final | W, 17-9 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Mary Washington * | Final | W, 18-9 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Wesley * | Final - 5 innings | W, 16-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Juniata | Final | L, 9-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| at Juniata | Final | L, 7-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| Wesley * | Final | W, 9-8 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mary Washington * | Final | W, 4-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 7 | St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | L, 8-1 | Box Score Recap |
| St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | L, 5-4 | Box Score Recap | |
| Mary Washington * | Final | L, 16-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 9 | Immaculata | Final | W, 6-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Frostburg St. * | Final | W, 23-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 10 | at Frostburg St. * | Final - 8 innings | L, 4-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Stevenson | Final | W, 9-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Frostburg St. * | Final | W, 11-4 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Frostburg St. * | Final - 6 innings | L, 14-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 11 | Haverford | Final | W, 10-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Apr. 12 | at Frostburg St. * | Final | L, 15-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Apr. 13 | at Johns Hopkins / Loyola Invitational @ Baltimore, Md. | Final | Results Recap | |
| at Johns Hopkins / Loyola Invitational @ Baltimore, Md. | Final | Results | ||
| at Mary Washington * | Final | L, 6-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Frostburg St. * | Final | L, 6-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Mary Washington * | Final | W, 11-9 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Mary Washington * | Final | L, 5-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Frostburg St. * | Final | W, 8-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mary Washington * | Final | L, 9-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 14 | at Glenmaura Collegiate Invitational | Final | Recap | |
| Glemaura National Golf Club - Day One | ||||
| at Frostburg St. * | Final | L, 7-2 | Box Score Recap | |
| at Frostburg St. * | Final | W, 9-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 15 | at Glenmaura Collegiate Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| Glemaura National Golf Club - Day Two | ||||
| Apr. 16 | Penn St.-Altoona | Final | W, 6-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at Mary Washington | Final | L, 4-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Tournament | ||||
| Penn St.-Altoona | Final - 9 innings | W, 4-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 17 | at Salisbury * | Final | L, 16-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Apr. 19 | at Susquehanna Invitational | Final | Results Recap | |
| Susquehanna Valley Country Club | ||||
| St. Mary's (Md.) @ Salisbury, Md. | Final | W, 15-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Second Round | ||||
| at Washington College | Final - 8 innings | L, 8-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Washington College | Final - 5 innings | W, 13-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 20 | at Moravian Greyhound Invitational @ Bethlehem, Pa. | Final | Results Recap | |
| at Wesley @ Salisbury, Md. | Final | W, 6-2 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Tournament | ||||
| at Wesley * | Final | W, 16-6 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Frostburg St. | Final | W, 8-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Touranment First Round | ||||
| Bridgewater (Va.) | Final | L, 10-4 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at St. Mary's (Md.) * | Final | W, 9-8 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Mary Washington @ Salisbury, Md. | Final | W, 2-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Bridgewater (Va.) | Final | L, 9-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 21 | at Salisbury | Final | L, 4-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| CAC Tournament Championship | ||||
| at Misericordia | Final - 8 innings | W, 9-8 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Frostburg St. | Final | L, 8-1 | Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Tournament First Round | ||||
| at Misericordia | Final | L, 3-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 22 | Rowan | Final - 10 innings | L, 7-6 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Apr. 23 | at Messiah Falcon Spring Classic | Final | Results Recap | |
| Blue Ridge Country Club | ||||
| Montclair St. | Final | W, 5-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Mary Washington | Final | L, 9-0 | Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Semifinals | ||||
| Wesley | Final | W, 8-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Play-In Game | ||||
| Apr. 25 | at Penn Relays @ Philadelphia, Pa. | Final | Recap | |
| Penn St.-Berks | Final | L, 6-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| Apr. 26 | at Salisbury | Final - 5 innings | L, 12-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| CAC Tournament | ||||
| at Mary Washington | Final - 6 innings | L, 8-0 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Tournament - Elimination Game | ||||
| Apr. 27 | at Shippensburg Paul Kaiser Classic @ Shippensburg, Pa. | Final | Results Recap | |
| at Capital Athletic Conference Championships | Final | Recap | ||
| Wild Quail Golf & Country Club | ||||
| Mary Washington | Final | W, 12-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Semifinal | ||||
| St. Mary's (Md.) | Final | L, 10-9 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Semifinals | ||||
| Apr. 28 | at Capital Athletic Conference Championships | Final | Results Recap | |
| Wild Quail Golf & Country Club | ||||
| at Ithaca | Final | L, 6-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| May. 1 | at Johns Hopkins | Final | W, 10-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| at McDaniel | Final | L, 6-1 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at McDaniel | Final | L, 9-7 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| May. 4 | at Capital Athletic Conference Outdoor Championships @ Salisbury, Md. * | Final | Results Recap | |
| at Randolph-Macon | Final | L, 13-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| at Salisbury | Final | L, 13-5 | Box Score Box Score Recap | |
| CAC Tournment Championship | ||||
| May. 5 | at Capital Athletic Conference Outdoor Championships @ Salisbury, Md. * | Final | Results Recap | |
| May. 8 | Washington and Lee | Final | W, 13-6 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| NCAA Tournament - First Round | ||||
| May. 9 | York Twilight Meet @ York, Pa. | Final | Preview Results Recap | |
| May. 11 | at Frank. & Marsh. @ Salisbury, Md. | Final | L, 10-9 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| NCAA Second Round | ||||
| May. 12 | Frank. & Marsh. | Final | W, 14-3 | Box Score Box Score Recap |
| Senior Day | ||||
| May. 13 | at Swathmore Tuppany Twilight Last Chance Meet @ Swarthmore, Pa. | Final | Recap | |
| May. 23 | at NCAA DIII Outdoor National Championships @ La Crosse, WI | 10:00 am | Preview Recap Live stats Video | |
| May. 24 | at NCAA DIII Outdoor National Championships @ La Crosse, WI | 10:00 am | Preview Live stats Video | |
| May. 25 | at NCAA DIII Outdoor National Championships @ La Crosse, WI | 10:00 am | Preview Live stats Video | |
| Home games in bold. * = Conference games. | ||||